ProBrewer.com

An Online Resource Serving The Beer Industry

  • News
    • News From The Breweries
    • Specialty Industry News
    • Major Brand News
    • Legislative & Regulatory
    • Distribution & Retail
    • Quarterly Financial Reports
    • International
    • Commentary
    • General News
  • Events
    • All Events
    • Essential Virtual Resources for the Brewing Industry
    • Virtual Brewing Conference Guide
  • Classified Ads
    • Latest Ads
    • Ads By Category
    • Help Wanted / For Hire
    • Search Ads
    • Post Classified Ad
    • Post Catalog Ad
    • About Classified Ads
  • Jobs
  • Discussion
  • Library
    • Archives
    • Brewery Floors
    • Brewstillery
    • Distilling
    • Distribution
    • ‘DIY’ floor coating
    • Electric Brewing
    • Filtration
    • Hops
    • Kegs
    • Keg Washers
    • Malt
    • Malt handling
    • Nano Breweries
    • Packaging
    • Pumps
    • Refrigeration
    • Shipping
    • Stupid Stuff
    • Turnkey
    • Used Tanks
    • Water
    • Yeast
  • Tools
    • IBU Calculator
    • Beer Specifications
    • Water Chemistry
  • Advertise
    • Advertise & Sponsorship on ProBrewer
    • ProBrewer Advertisers
  • Allied Trade Directory
    • Search Allied Trade Directory
    • Your Companies
    • Submit New Allied Trade Company
  • Login / Register
    • Login to ProBrewer
    • Discussions Login
    • Register
    • Password Reset
You are here: Home / General News / Alcohol shipping showdown

Alcohol shipping showdown

June 1, 2004

The Supreme Court agreed this week to decide if states can ban direct shipments of wine to consumers from out-of-state wineries. Ultimately, the decision could also affect smaller breweries that hope to sell directly to consumers, bypassing traditional distribution channels.

A number of lawsuits have been brought challenging the bans for unconstitutionally discriminating against interstate commerce. Defenders of the laws argued that states under the 21st Amendment, which repealed Prohibition, have the power to regulate the sale and distribution of alcoholic beverages.

The justices agreed to review cases from Michigan and New York in an attempt to resolve conflicting appeals court rulings.

At issue is the system of alcohol distribution under which out-of-state wine producers may sell only to wholesalers, who distribute to retailers, who in turn sell to consumers. About half of the states have direct shipping prohibitions. Some laws ban direct shipments from out-of-state wineries, but allow direct sales from wineries within the state.

Michigan Attorney General Michael Cox appealed to the Supreme Court. He said Congress delegated to the states the right to regulate the shipment and transportation of alcoholic beverages within its borders. Cox said Michigan’s system screens out shipments from outside the state to prevent sales to minors and to ensure that state taxes are collected.

Opponents of the Michigan law described the ban as protectionist, discriminatory and anti-consumer.

The Supreme Court appeal in the New York case was brought by those challenging the law, including two small family-run wineries in Virginia and California and three New York wine drinkers. Their lawyers said there are more than 2,500 wineries in 49 states, and most of the wineries outside the top 25 are family-run enterprises producing fewer than 5,000 cases a year. They said the Internet now makes possible direct sales to consumers.

The lawyers also cited a staff report by the Federal Trade Commission last year that found that the bans reduce consumer choice and increase wine prices.

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Twitter
  • Pocket
  • Email
Pat Hagerman

Posted by Pat Hagerman

Pat Hagerman is co-founder of ProBrewer.com. When he's not leading operations for ProBrewer you can find Pat working on Internet of Things (IoT) infrastructure and systems. If you're having a beer with him ask about some of the more original skills he's taught Alexa.

Search

Promoted
Schaefer Container Systems North America Inc. logo
Schaefer Container Systems North America Inc.
Kegs and Tanks Direct from the Manufacturer
Craftmaster Stainless logo
Craftmaster Stainless
Serving the craft brewery, wine, and distilling industries.
Precision Fermentation, Inc. logo
Precision Fermentation, Inc.
Creator's of the BrewMonitor System
Micropure Filtration • MaltHandling.com, LLC

Subscribe to ProBrewer Daily

ProBrewer Subscriptions

View previous newsletters.

Connect With @ProBrewerPage

 Instagram    Facebook    Twitter

 

 

 

Join the ProBrewer mailing list

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy

Connect With @ProBrewerPage

 Instagram    Facebook    Twitter

Go Somewhere Else

News • Classifieds • Help Wanted / For Hire • Discussion • Library • Contact • Advertise • Contact Details • Help

Copyright © 2021 · RealBeer Media · Privacy Policy · Terms and Conditions

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.